Skip to content
Csbibliography

Annotated Bibliography of Christian Science

Academic and Other Literature

  • Home
  • About
    • About the ABCS Project
    • Support Opportunities (Donate)
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Annotations
    • Search Information
    • Category Search
    • Keyword Search
    • Advanced Search
    • Standard Search
    • Authors/Editor List
    • Title List
    • Recently Added
    • Search Support
  • Resources
    • The Book
    • Online Resources
    • ABCS Blog
    • Suggest Resources
  • Contact
Annotation Resource

“Historical Consensus and Christian Science: The Career of a Manuscript Controversy”

“Historical Consensus and Christian Science: The Career of a Manuscript Controversy”

Johnsen, Thomas C. “Historical Consensus and Christian Science: The Career of a Manuscript Controversy.” The New England Quarterly 53, no. 1 (March 1980): 3–22. 

Johnsen’s 1980 overview of the multi-decade controversy over a forgery highlights “the power of consensus myths to shape and even dominate historical perceptions” (3) that endure long after the falsities have been exposed. Walter M. Haushalter claimed in his 1936 publication of Mrs. Eddy Purloins from Hegel to have found a handwritten manuscript by Francis Lieber, a 19th-century political scientist, entitled “The Metaphysical Religion of Hegel.” He further claimed that the document appeared in the attic papers of an uneducated early student of Mary Baker Eddy’s. Haushalter’s book was praised by virtually all of its reviewers, and the ensuing battle over public perceptions was fought over a clear forgery. Research leading to the discovery of forgery was not difficult, because handwriting experts quickly detected the “astonishingly crude and obvious” fraud (6). Despite the fact that four Johns Hopkins professors had given their scholarly imprimatur, Frank Freidel, Lieber’s biographer, initiated questions; and Baptist professor and church historian Conrad Moehlman (in Ordeal by Concordance) demonstrated that in fact a significant portion of “The Metaphysical Religion of Hegel” had been plagiarized from Eddy. As further motives for the forgery came to light, the Christian Science church chose to remain mostly silent, expecting the obvious truth to settle the matter.

ISSN: 1937-2213
Print ISSN: 0028-4866

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/365286

 

See also annotations: 

Mrs. Eddy Purloins from Hegel: Newly Discovered Source Reveals Amazing Plagiarisms in Science and Health by Mrs. Walter M. Haushalter

Ordeal by Concordance: Historian Explodes the Lieber Myth by Conrad Moehlman

 

Johnsen, Thomas C.

Related Annotations:

Annotations related by category:
  • Availability: Online - Academic Credentials or Fee
  • Controversy: Plagiarism
  • Official Christian Science Publication: No
  • People: Eddy, Mary Baker
  • People: Hegel, George
  • Publication Date: 1956-1980
  • Resource Types: Article
  • Subjects: Metaphysical
  • Subjects: Polemic Literature and Responses
  • Subjects: Science and Health Book
Annotations related by keyword:
  • Ethics
More by authors or editor(s):
  • Johnsen, Thomas

Comment on this resource: Cancel

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Search Home

Search application instructions and overview.

Search Support

Questions? We've got answers.

Category Search

Select subject, person, organization and/or controversy to provide a subset of annotation results. The results page includes the ability to further limit your search.

Keyword Search

Select one or more specific keywords to provide a subset of annotation results. The results page includes the ability to further limit your search.

Advanced Search

Select from all search options to obtain very specific results.

Standard Search

Might yield a mix of relevant and irrelevant results, but could be very helpful if you are looking for a specific term not included in any of the other types of searches.

Annotations by Author
Annotations by Title
Most Recent

View the 30 most recently added annotations.

New Since the Book

View new annotations available here that were not included in the book.

Suggest a Resource
Donate via PayPal

Scholarly Works on Christian Science is the nonprofit corporation that produces the ABCS website. We rely on donations to keep the bibliography updated and available to the public. If you find this site useful we hope you'll consider donating to support the work. Donate via PayPal by clicking the button above or send a check to:

Scholarly Works on Christian Science
420 Conway Meadows Drive
St. Louis, MO 63017

© 2022 and later by Scholarly Works on Christian Science, all rights reserved.

Privacy Policy is here. Cookie Policy is here. Comment Policy is here.

This material was printed from the Annotated Bibliography of Christian Science website produced and maintained by Scholarly Works on Christian Science (https://csbibliography.org). All rights reserved.