Stiles examines Christian Science novels written in the early 1900s in light of Mary Baker Eddy’s views on what she calls nauseous fiction. Specifically, Stiles studies Eddy’s correspondence with, and tentative support of, Christian Scientist authors of some of the more wholesome fictions for youth, comparing these with the more secular novelists writing for youth who often mixed Christian Science and New Thought beliefs.
View AnnotationKeyword Search Results
The resources that matched your keyword selections are listed below. Click the resource title to view the complete annotation. On each annotation page you have the ability to find related annotations based on certain criteria.
If you’d like to limit your results, you can use the following dropdowns to do so.
Keep in mind that the more limiting factors you select in the dropdowns, the more likely you are to get a null result.
If you don’t see any results it’s likely because you selected too many keywords in your LIMIT search. Most annotations are associated with just a few keywords. Selecting more than three keywords is likely to lead to very few or no results.
Clicking the button above will replace the results below with results limited to only the annotations that fit the criteria you selected in the dropdown menus.
53 Search Results
“A New Christian Identity: Christian Science Origins and Experience in American Culture by Amy B. Voorhees” (review) (2022)
Amy B. Voorhees’s A New Christian Identity offers a concise, culturally informed study of Mary Baker Eddy, Science and Health, and the rise of Christian Science. While noting some minor errors, reviewer Judy Huenneke sees the book as a valuable resource for readers of American religious history and women’s religious leadership, and she praises its sympathetic, well-researched approach, and insightful context.
View Annotation“Psychotherapy and the Psychotherapeutic Relationship in Historical Context: New Thought, Christian Science, and the Emmanuel Movement” (2021)
The derivation of psychotherapy is examined through the contributions of 19th-century American mind-cure movements and personalities such as Swedenborgianism, spiritualism, Phineas Parkhurst Quimby, Warren Felt Evans, New Thought, Christian Science, and the Emmanuel Movement. These movements’ focus on the connection between the healer and sufferer made them precursors of contemporary psychotherapy’s relation-based methods.
View AnnotationA New Christian Identity: Christian Science Origins and Experience in American Culture (2021)
Voorhees offers new scholarship on a broad array of topics related to Christian Science identity focusing on reception history. With attention to fully resourced details and modern scholarship, Voorhees outlines the reception history of Christian Science in fields of religion, women studies, American history, politics, medicine, and metaphysics. She probes Mary Baker Eddy’s relationships with contemporary scholars, religion leaders, and students.
View Annotation“New Thought and the Inner Child in Frances Hodgson Burnett’s Little Lord Fauntleroy” (2018)
Stiles examines late nineteenth-century literary references to the “inner child,” defined as “a person’s original or true self,” in the writings of New Thought authors. She highlights the maternal imagery of Mary Baker Eddy’s church and identifies Frances Hodgson Burnett’s book Little Lord Fauntleroy as a prominent example of literature portraying the child as a model of health and optimism.
View Annotation“Western Esoteric Family IV: Christian Science-Metaphysical” in Melton’s Encyclopedia of American Religions (2017)
The focus of this article is an explanation of Christian Science within the religious context of its American origin and development. Melton claims that Mesmerism, Spiritualism, Swedenborgianism, and Transcendentalism prepared the way for two important religious movements of the 19th- century: Christian Science and New Thought. The author also gives relative importance to the role of independent Christian Scientists.
View AnnotationHealing the Nation: Literature, Progress, and Christian Science by L. Ashley Squires (Review) (2017)
Stiles’ review of L. Ashley Squires’ Healing the Nation highlights its contribution to American literary studies by addressing its neglect of Christian Science. Squires provides crucial historical context explaining authors’ varied responses to the faith and offers fresh interpretations of overlooked texts. Blending literary analysis with history, journalism, and biography, the book makes a compelling case for renewed scholarly attention.
View Annotation“Christian Science and American Literary History” (2016)
Squires sees the opening of the Mary Baker Eddy Library as an opportunity for literary scholars to give closer attention to the history, doctrines, and distinctions of Christian Science. Only then will there be an honest and accurate account for the literature that seeks to represent or critique them.
View Annotation“Christian Science Versus The Rest Cure in Frances Hodgson Burnett’s The Secret Garden” (2015)
Stiles demonstrates the difficulty of understanding the literary work of Burnett’s early twentieth-century book, The Secret Garden, because the concepts of healing are so different now. Mitchell’s rest cure was popular, but its regimen was demoralizing. Rejecting rest cure, Burnett embraced Christian Science and its offshoot, New Thought, for herself, and her novels highlight educated women eschewing conventional medicine in favor of faith healing movements.
View Annotation“Webcast: Evolutions of Christian Science in Scholarly Perspective” (2015)
This panel of scholars—J. Gordon Melton, Massimo Introvigne, and Shirley Paulson—explored the contemporary scholarly perspective on Christian Science. Melton pointed out that the maturity of the study of Christian Science should go beyond the issue of classification; Introvigne illustrated how scholarship in art deepens the meaning of religious study; and Paulson focused on the Christian origin of Christian Science.
View Annotation“Think Positive” (2014)
Janik traces the historical path of mesmerism from Franz Mesmer’s late 18th-century theories on animal magnetism, leading to de Puysegur’s discovery of hypnosis, to Charles Poyan’s 1830 lecture tour introducing mesmerism and hypnotism to New England, to Phineas Quimby’s mind cure practice, to Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science movement, to New Thought and eventually today’s clinical psychology.
View Annotation“Metaphysical Healing and Health in the United States” (2014)
Hendrickson discusses the American history of metaphysical healing practices from Native Americans to the present and identifies characteristics of diverse types of healing. Mary Baker Eddy and Christian Science are discussed within the context of Quimbyism and New Thought, with the distinction made between the Christian basis of Eddy and the more materialistic, secular basis of the latter.
View Annotation“New Thought’s Prosperity Theology and its Influence on American Ideas of Success” (2014)
Hutchinson defines New Thought as any American metaphysical religion affiliated with Phineas P. Quimby, Mary Baker Eddy and Emma Curtis Hopkins. They expanded from their emphasis on healing to a focus on prosperity theology; and Hutchinson observes that since Eddy rejected materialism, the New Thought emphasis on prosperity—while popular in mainstream Christian America—differentiated it from Christian Science.
View AnnotationOne Simple Idea: How Positive Thinking Reshaped Modern Life (2014)
Horowitz assigns Christian Science a prominent place in the development of American affirmative-thinking (his term) philosophical systems. Although he acknowledges Mary Baker Eddy’s interest in Quimby (a 19th-century mesmerist) and her debt to him during a prolonged time of illness, Horowitz believes that Quimby was not the founder of Christian Science. Instead, Eddy herself created a brigade of spiritual freethinkers.
View Annotation“Writing Revelation: Mary Baker Eddy and Her Early Editions of Science and Health, 1875-1891” (2013)
…her textbook as co-pastor in 1894. Finally, she profiles those who studied Eddy’s textbook and practiced “the principle or science behind the healing in the Christian Scriptures” (14). Access…
View Annotation“‘A General Revolt in the Name of Soul’: The Mind-Cure and Psychotherapy Movement in America” (2013)
Bessette analyzes the historical milieu that resulted in the late Victorian era’s “birth of the therapeutic.” Besides Mary Baker Eddy, Bessette taps into the various social, religious and psychosomatic thinkers of this period along with the New Thought and Emmanuel movements, and how they shaped a more unified “whole man” view of mind and body.
View Annotation“The Tragedy of Desire: Christian Science in Theodore Dreiser’s The Genius” (2013)
Squires takes up the 1915 novel, “The Genius,” by Theodore Dreiser and compares the many semi-autobiographical parallels between the novel’s main character, Eugene, and Dreiser. Dreiser’s personal philandering and materialism are reflected in his portrayal of Eugene. After scandalous affairs with tragic consequences, both grapple with their own crisis of morality by conversing with Mary Baker Eddy’s teachings in Christian Science.
View Annotation“The Christian Scientists” in America: Religions and Religion (2012)
Albanese’s undergraduate textbook explains Christian Science in the context of the evolution of religions and the meaning of religion in America. Christian Science was one of the 19th-century new religions that made considerable demands on its members, as new sects often did. Albanese’s theological explanations of Christian Science are based on her thorough knowledge of the American metaphysical movement.
View Annotation“Understanding the Religious Gulf between Mary Baker Eddy, Ursula N. Gestefeld, and Their Churches” (2011)
The commonly mischaracterized and consequently overlooked relationship between Eddy and her former student, Gestefeld, should be re-examined because of its rich theological and biographical potential. Voorhees’s closer look at their correspondence indicates a mutually respectful relationship before they parted ways on grounds of theological differences—Gestefeld’s theosophical eclecticism versus Eddy’s unorthodox Christian particularism, and not because of Eddy’s authoritarian reasons.
View Annotation“Harmonialism and Metaphysical Religion” in Volume 2 of Encyclopedia of Religion in America (2010)
Ivey presents historical context for the 19th-century emergence of metaphysical religions and their evolution into the 20th century. He highlights the inter-relationships between the practice of Phineas Quimby, Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science, and the ensuing movements. Ivey differentiates the theology of Christian Science from Quimby and New Thought—with the human mind acting as a conduit between spirit and matter.
View Annotation“Christian Science and New Thought” (2007)
Ivey chronicles the late 19th century expansion of both New Thought and Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science church in the Midwest: the graduates of Eddy’s Massachusetts Metaphysical College who established institutes in six Midwest cities, the most important early organizers of Christian Science services, the establishment of The Principia as an independent school, and New Thought’s Emma Curtis Hopkins many organizers.
View Annotation“Introduction: Awash in a Sea of Metaphysics” (2007)
Albanese’s study of the meaning and role of metaphysics in American religious development includes magical practices (which she equates to healing), Spiritualism, occultism, theosophy, and extra- and post-Christian concerns such as Christian Science. She distances such metaphysics from Gnosticism and from Ahlstrom’s rubric of harmonialism. But significantly, it has played a key role in the culture of the modern state.
View AnnotationA Republic of Mind and Spirit: A Cultural History of American Metaphysical Religion (2007)
Albanese identifies three major forms of religion in America: evangelical, liturgical, and metaphysical, claiming that the key to understanding religion in America is the influence of the metaphysical on the others.She locates Christian Science in a continuum of 19th-century metaphysical expressions from Andrew Jackson Davis and Spiritualism to Phineas P. Quimby and then influencing directly and indirectly a wide range of New Thought offshoots.
View Annotation“Christian Science” in Vol. 2 of the Encyclopedia of Women and Religion in North America (2006)
Cunningham provides a thorough introduction to the life of Mary Baker Eddy, theological distinctions of Christian Science, the Church founding, evolution of the Church Manual, more recent developments such as recent legal and financial struggles, the opening of the Mary Baker Eddy Library, and whether Eddy and her followers were feminists.
View Annotation“Neurotheology and Spiritual Transformation: Clues in the Work of Joel Goldsmith” (2004)
Based on a hypothesis from neuroscience—that the human brain is wired for spirituality—Simmons posits a universal process of spiritual transformation in three stages and claims that Mary Baker Eddy has experienced the third: experiencing mystical unity with God. But she retreated at times to a paradoxical duality when forming her theology and church organization.
View AnnotationBorn Again Bodies: Flesh and Spirit in American Christianity (2004)
Griffith investigates the roots of Christian dieting and fitness and their present-day embodiments. One chapter explores 19th-century mind-cure movements, including Phineas P. Quimby, Christian Science and New Thought, with their connection between mind and matter. She sees in Mary Baker Eddy a contradiction between her radical stance on body as delusion and her rich living circumstances.
View Annotation“Christian Science, Jewish Science, and Alfred Geiger Moses” (2003)
Umansky analyzes the evolution of Rabbi Alfred Moses’s teachings identified as Jewish Science, as found in his two books responding to the early twentieth-century exodus of Jews to Christian Science. His first book specifically contrasts Christian Science with Jewish Science. Seeking a practical faith as a counter to Christian Science, the second book is influenced by both psychology and New Thought.
View Annotation“New Thinking, New Thought, New Age: The Theology and Influence of Emma Curtis Hopkins (1849-1925)” (2002)
Michell examines the influences, and theological connections and differences, between the teachings of Mary Baker Eddy, Emma Curtis Hopkins, the 19th-century Woman’s movement, and the New Thought and New Age movements. Hopkins, unlike Eddy, would see Truth in all religions, not limited to Christianity, and focused more on a prosperity gospel.
View Annotation“The Eddy-Hopkins Paradigm: A ‘Metaphysical Look’ at Their Historic Relationship” (2002)
Simmons explores the reasons for the parting of ways between Mary Baker Eddy and one of her followers, Emma Curtis Hopkins. He speculates that the Hopkins-Eddy relationship embodied the second and third stages in the process of spiritual transformation where Hopkins moved through Christian Science and “graduated” to a higher spiritual level.
View AnnotationAmerica’s Religions: From Their Origins to the Twenty-First Century (2002)
This graduate level textbook on America’s religions intertwines a wide multitude of religious belief systems with the multi-faceted movements of American thought. Williams explains Christian Science in the context of 19th- and 20th-century American culture, which includes harmonialism, individualism, female empowerment, and cult–a term evangelists equate with theological deviancy but is otherwise characterized by charismatic leadership and isolation from the rest of the world.
View AnnotationEmma Curtis Hopkins: Forgotten Founder of New Thought (2002)
This well-researched biography of Emma Curtis Hopkins, little-known founder of the 19th-century New Thought movement, includes Hopkins’s early-stage affiliation with Mary Baker Eddy—her tutelage by Eddy and editorship of The Christian Science Journal for 13 months before being suddenly discharged. Harley draws on a range of scholarship to contextualize the complexity of this knotty developmental stage of Christian Science.
View AnnotationMrs. Stanton’s Bible (2001)
Seeing no social change favoring women’s rights, suffragist Elizabeth Cady Stanton switched her energies to addressing the underlying issue of women’s subordination rooted in the Bible. Like Mary Baker Eddy’s opus, Science and Health, Stanton’s Women’s Bible was intended as a vehicle for emancipation. Kern includes Eddy among the many women bearing (indirect) influence on Stanton’s story.
View AnnotationEach Mind a Kingdom: American Women, Sexual Purity, and the New Thought Movement, 1875–1920 (1999)
Both Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science movement and the New Thought Movement flourished in the late 19th-and early 20th-centuries. They agreed that one’s mental fears foster illness and distress. Yet unlike the New Thought Movement—believing in the human mind’s ability to control the world—Eddy thought a reliance on the mortal mind’s power distracted from one’s reliance on God.
View AnnotationFits, Trances, and Visions: Experiencing Religion and Explaining Experience from Wesley to James (1999)
Taves’s work is a study of religious experience with a focus on the difference between the indwelling Spirit of God and a lively imagination. Although Mary Baker Eddy was a patient and student of Phineas Quimby’s, Taves identifies the crucial distinction between them through Eddy’s differentiation of spirit from matter. Quimby valued both states simultaneously whereas Eddy held them in complete opposition.
View Annotation“The Christian Science Tradition” (1998)
…the Bible, to the status of Pastor, codification of policy in the Church Manual, and establishment of the Christian Science Publishing Society. “…Eddy best displayed her genius through a subtle…
View AnnotationMary Baker Eddy (1998)
Gill, a feminist historian and biographer, offers a fresh view of Mary Baker Eddy’s achievements in the light of obstacles faced by women in her time. Without access to Church archives Gill relied on Peel’s archival research. Gill’s unique contribution challenges the traditional biographers’ view of Eddy as a hysterical invalid who abandoned her son and stole her ideas.
View Annotation“The Case of Edward J. Arens and the Distortion of the History of New Thought” (1996)
Melton argues that the history of the Eddy-Quimby debates obscured other important historical facts, besides the truth about both Eddy and Quimby. From Melton’s closer look at this case, he concludes that Evans could not be the founder of New Thought, and that Mary Baker Eddy—not Quimby—must be the true founder of Christian Science.
View Annotation“New Thought’s Hidden History: Emma Curtis Hopkins, Forgotten Founder” (1995)
Melton’s uncovering of a largely forgotten history of the relationship between Mary Baker Eddy and Emma Curtis Hopkins provides historians of religion an insightful comparison between two successful women of the 19th century. Although the article’s focus is on Hopkins, her relationship with Eddy illustrates both similarities and dissimilarities in the women and their churches.
View Annotation“Christian Science and New Thought in California: Seeking Health, Happiness and Prosperity in Paradise” (1993)
Christian Science and New Thought both conveyed a “metaphysical perfectionism” in sync with late 19th-century American can-do spirit and the golden glow of California culture with its promises of prosperity. Key women in Christian Science left the movement to become teachers and prime movers of New Thought in California. Other reasons for the decline in both movements today are discussed.
View Annotation“Christian Science” in Vol. 3 of Encyclopedia of Religion (1993)
Gottschalk’s overview of Christian Science sees it as not philosophically derived but based on the works and salvation of Jesus, a new interpretation of the gospel, and the “operation of divine power comprehended as spiritual law.” Gottschalk compares Christian Science and traditional Christian views, as well as distinguishes it from idealism, pantheism, mind cure, and New Thought.
View Annotation“Emma Curtis Hopkins: A Feminist of the 1880s and Mother of New Thought” (1993)
Because Emma Curtis Hopkins identified herself as an independent Christian Scientist, her successful establishment of her own religious following provides a valuable comparison with Eddy’s Christian Science. Although Hopkins’s theological teaching was quite similar to Mary Baker Eddy’s, Hopkins emphasized some aspects of it—such as her larger implications of God’s identity as Mother—while still operating within ecclesiastical Christianity.
View AnnotationNew Religions and the Theological Imagination in America (1989)
Bednarowski compares Christian Science and Scientology, two religions often confused. Both Christian Science and Scientology radically seek an understanding of God and reality which the physical world obscures. Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science emerged from Christ-centered revelation and a deep study of the healing message of the Bible. L. Ron Hubbard’s Scientology and terminology is more psychological, taking the form of self-help.
View Annotation“Woman’s Hour: Feminist Implications of Mary Baker Eddy’s Christian Science Movement, 1885-1910” (1981)
Hansen examines the formative period of the Christian Science movement and discovers not only restorations of health but also healing as a religious act. From this, Hansen distinguishes Christian Science from the women metaphysical healers of the same period who eventually formed the New Thought movement. Eddy’s declaration, “This is woman’s hour” conveys the female contribution to Christian Science.
View Annotation“New Spirit, New Flesh: The Poetics of Nineteenth-Century Mind-Cures.” (1980)
Sizer argues that the multiple forms of mind cure of the 19th century arose from the metaphoric and poetic language of the 18th century. She traces threads of old metaphors used by mind-cure systems to justify themselves against the theories of orthodox medicine. Mary Baker Eddy went even further toward transcendentalism in Science and Health, using emotional, musical, or visceral metaphors.
View AnnotationThe Positive Thinkers: Religion as Pop Psychology from Mary Baker Eddy to Oral Roberts (1980)
Meyer’s purpose was to assess religion as therapy: as a cult of reassurance, as psychology of peace and positive thinking. After a brief biography of Mary Baker Eddy’s life, Meyer positions Christian Science as a kind of psychotherapy dressed in religious attire —mind cure’s tightly organized, exclusive denomination. However, his perception is based on very few and dated resources.
View Annotation“A Typology of American Restitutionism: From Frontier Revivalism and Mormonism to the Jesus Movement” (1976)
Looking at Protestant denominations originating in 19th-/early 20th-century America, Hill examines how each works to bring about a restitution of the original ‘paradigmatic’ Jesus movement which is held to have exclusive authority. Hill cites different types of restitutionalism: institutional, ‘born again,’ Holy Spirit possession, and restoration of the eternal principles practiced by Jesus (Christian Science being an example).
View AnnotationThe Emergence of Christian Science in American Religious Life (1973)
Gottschalk was a Christian Scientist whose 1973 book was a more frank presentation than previous accounts of Mary Baker Eddy’s life by an insider. For instance, although he claims that Christian Science is the only true Christian religion, he criticizes Christian Scientists for certain attitudes and behaviors that reveal a shallow understanding of Eddy and the rigor of Christian Science practice.
View AnnotationA Religious History of the American People (1972)
Although Ahlstrom’s widely accepted categorization of ‘harmonial religion’ has been critiqued and somewhat abandoned in more recent scholarship, his 1972 analysis of American religious history made a significant impact on religious scholarship. Ahlstrom identifies Christian Science as the most clearly defined and best organized of five harmonial religions.
View AnnotationMary Baker Eddy: The Years of Trial (1971)
Volume two of Peel’s trilogy covers Mary Baker Eddy’s expanding years of 1877 to 1891, her crucial period of trial and error as she fights for the survival of her nascent movement. She organizes her church, clarifies her revolutionary interpretation of the Bible, and teaches pupils who will carry the message of Christian Science beyond New England to a wider world.
View AnnotationThe History and Philosophy of the Metaphysical Movements in America (1967)
Judah’s 1967 monograph on the metaphysical movements of 20th-century America remains a valuable resource for a comparison between movements and a documentation of their impact on organized Protestant Christianity. Regarding Christian Science, Judah claims most of its basic biblical doctrinal points are similar to the beliefs of historic Protestantism, but their full explanations place them outside traditional Christian theology.
View AnnotationSpirits in Rebellion: The Rise and Development of New Thought (1963)
Scholars seeking to differentiate between Christian Science and New Thought will appreciate Braden’s history of their origins. Although Braden’s purpose was to explain the various New Thought communities and their origins, their stories are intertwined for various reasons with Mary Baker Eddy and the establishment of her movement, Christian Science. Controversies arose over differences and similarities with Quimby and with Eddy.
View AnnotationMary Baker Eddy: A Life Size Portrait (1930)
Powell’s 1930 work intentionally challenges Dakin’s Biography of a Virginal Mind. It also contrasts with Powell’s own 1907 work, Christian Science: The Faith and Its Founder, which presented a far more negative view of Christian Science and Mary Baker Eddy. Powell, an Episcopal clergyman and an academic writer, made good use of his considerable access to the Church’s archival collections.
View AnnotationChristian Science and the Catholic Faith: Including a Brief Account of New Thought and Other Modern Mental Healing Movements (1922)
If Bellwald had had access to archival resources on Christian Science, he might have made a more accurate comparison between Christian Science and Roman Catholicism of the early twentieth century. His organizational approach to his study is well conceived, but he combines the resources of blatant polemics, Milmine and Peabody, with his own Catholic perspectives to denounce Christian Science.
View Annotation