In 1953, Anglican church leaders created a commission of clergy and doctors seeking a clearer understanding of divine healing, its role in their ministry, and their relationship with medical practitioners. The final report grounded it in the medical sciences and found little common ground between spiritual healing and the Anglican Church’s embedding of its healing ministry in the ritual and creed of the Church.
View AnnotationResources Discussing Medicine
The resources related to the topic of medicine are listed below. Click “View Annotation” to learn more about the resource.
To limit these results by publication date range, resource type, availability and/or whether or not the resource is an official Christian Science publication, click here.
On each individual annotation page you will have the ability to find related annotations based on several different criteria.
70 Results
“Personal Experiences of the Christian Science Faith during COVID” (2023)
In this book of personal essays, people representing a variety of faiths respond to questions about the Covid pandemic and its impact on their spiritual practice. Susan Searle writes from a Christian Scientist viewpoint, and explains that she accepted vaccination in order to continue her public ministry.
View Annotation“Practising My Christian Science Faith during the COVID-19 Pandemic” (2023)
Shirley Paulson responds to questions about the Covid pandemic and its impact on the practice of her faith, Christian Science. She discusses how the pandemic experience highlighted the need for greater maturity in spiritual healing practices, such as more concern for public issues and greater spiritual clarity, strength, and authority.
View Annotation“A Forensic Analysis of Calvin Frye’s Diaries” (2021)
Due to the long-standing debate over Mary Baker Eddy’s use of morphine, the Mary Baker Eddy Library sought to resolve it in order to restore focus on Eddy’s larger record. Calvin Frye’s diaries had recorded several instances of Eddy’s use of morphine, but some claimed his diaries had been altered. A forensic analysis in 2021 concluded the diaries are reliable.
View Annotation“Psychotherapy and the Psychotherapeutic Relationship in Historical Context: New Thought, Christian Science, and the Emmanuel Movement” (2021)
The derivation of psychotherapy is examined through the contributions of 19th-century American mind-cure movements and personalities such as Swedenborgianism, spiritualism, Phineas Parkhurst Quimby, Warren Felt Evans, New Thought, Christian Science, and the Emmanuel Movement. These movements’ focus on the connection between the healer and sufferer made them precursors of contemporary psychotherapy’s relation-based methods.
View AnnotationA New Christian Identity: Christian Science Origins and Experience in American Culture (2021)
Voorhees offers new scholarship on a broad array of topics related to Christian Science identity focusing on reception history. With attention to fully resourced details and modern scholarship, Voorhees outlines the reception history of Christian Science in fields of religion, women studies, American history, politics, medicine, and metaphysics. She probes Mary Baker Eddy’s relationships with contemporary scholars, religion leaders, and students.
View Annotation“Vaccination: What did Eddy Say?” (2020)
Eddy’s first published reference to the subject of vaccination was in an 1880 sermon. In 1900, Eddy was consulted by some Christian Science parents, including her son, who wanted to keep their children from school due to their opposition to vaccination laws. But Eddy recommended compliance with the law and affirmed that one could also submit to the providence of God.
View Annotation“‘God is My First Aid Kit’: Negotiation of Health and Illness among Christian Scientists” (2018)
Steckler and Bartkowski seek to contribute to the scholarly understanding of how religious culture can be transformed through the lived experience of devout adherents. Using theories of subcultural identity and cultural repertoires to understand how Christian Scientists engage social challenges, they conclude that healing treatment options are more flexible and nuanced than often publicized, and other high-tension religions can benefit from a comparison.
View Annotation“Western Esoteric Family IV: Christian Science-Metaphysical” in Melton’s Encyclopedia of American Religions, Canada (2017)
The metaphysical nature of the religious belief and practice of Christian Science triggered theological, ecclesial, legal, medical, scientific, and moral controversies. Mary Baker Eddy also dealt with stress and trauma throughout her life. The metaphysical aspect of Christian Science does not detract from its practicality in human experience, as the metaphysically induced healing is evidence of the full salvation to come.
View Annotation“Science, Religion, and the Rhetoric of Revelation: The Case of the Christian Science Board of Lectureship” (2016)
Stob is interested in the rhetoric used by early Christian Science lecturers, who were active during the American Progressive Era, to convince the public that Christian Science was worth investigating. These lectures effectively used novel language that expands the parameters of revelatory discourse. Eddy and her lecturers moved divine revelation from an other-worldly mystery into a framework for individual agency.
View Annotation“Alan Rogers. The Child Cases: How America’s Religious Exemption Laws Harm Children” (2015)
Schoepflin’s review acknowledges the relevance of Rogers’s study of America’s religious exemption from vaccination in light of the then-current 2015 measles outbreak in the United States—even though Rogers primarily uses case studies of Christian Science practice from 30–35 years prior to his study to argue his case that children are harmed by exemption laws.
View Annotation“Church of Christ, Scientist (Christian Science)” in Handbook of Denominations in the United States (2014)
The section in this book devoted specifically to Christian Science is relatively brief, but the descriptions of the teachings and church structure accurately portray the issues most commonly affirmed by adherents. Topics of criticism also reflect the most common concerns from religious, medical, and social perspectives.
View Annotation“Truly a Liberated Woman: Tehilla Lichtenstein and Her Unique Role in the History of American Judaism” (2014)
The Society of Jewish Science was a response to the mass conversion of Jews, particularly women, to Christian Science. Its purpose was to revive a growing secular Judaism with elements Lichtenstein feared had been lost: healing, personal prayer, and belief in the Divine Spirit within. Unlike Christian Science, the Society did not reject medicine or deny the reality of matter.
View Annotation“Christian Science” in An Encyclopedia of Religion and American Cultures: Tradition, Diversity and Popular Expression (2014)
Fraser, a harsh critic of Christian Science, focuses on the history of its health practices in relation to the development of Western medicine. Eddy “left a movement that American society found simultaneously appealing (in its emphasis on Emersonian self-reliance) and troubling (for its wholesale rejection of medicine).”
View AnnotationA World More Bright: The Life of Mary Baker Eddy (2013)
Although written for young readers, “A World More Bright” contains details for those interested in the personal side of Mary Baker Eddy’s life story. For those more familiar with other biographies on Eddy, this book offers new facts that may be useful for filling in gaps of historical interest. Typical biographical controversies are mentioned but not critiqued by the authors.
View Annotation“Complementary and Alternative Medicine” (2012)
The two paragraphs devoted to an explanation of Christian Science healing practices present a view solely from the perspective of medicine. The article argues that Christian Science practitioners cannot perform a number of ordinary medical procedures such as a diagnosis of illness. Butler expresses concern that those who are not healed might become depressed or conclude they are unworthy.
View Annotationfathermothergod: My Journey Out of Christian Science (2011)
Greenhouse’s memoir is her sad story of her mother’s death from what might have been medically treatable cancer. Her parents practiced what might be called a ‘radical reliance’ form of Christian Science, the religion that Lucia admittedly never understood or adopted. Fearing “mental malpractice” (the teaching that negative thoughts of others can be harmful), her parents kept the illness a painful secret.
View Annotation“A Metaphysical Rocket in Gotham: The Rise of Christian Science in New York City, 1885-1910” (2010)
Bibliographer Swensen provides a social profile of the membership, internal operations and founding leadership (Augusta Stetson and Laura Lathrop) of the two largest Christian Science churches in the eastern U.S.—First and Second Church, New York City. Accessing the church records and the extensive correspondence between Mary Baker Eddy and New York church members, Swensen sees his study as a window into the rocket-rise of this vibrant new movement as a whole.
View Annotation“Christian Science” in Vol. 1 of the Encyclopedia of Religion in America (2010)
Ivey’s history of Christian Science covers a broad range of topics including a brief history of Eddy’s personal preparation for the founding of the Church, the healing theology of Christian Science, the establishment of the Church, broader contexts of the appeal of Christian Science, the role of language for its expression, the maturing years in the early 20th century, and the challenges of adapting to a changing world in the late 20th century.
View Annotation“What More in the Name of God? Theologies and Theodicies of Faith Healing” (2010)
Campbell seeks to identify and critique three central issues concerning communities who practice Christian healing without medicine: their theological justification for such healing practices, medical practices as morally and metaphysically wrong from their perspectives, and their understanding of theodicy when healing does not occur. But a glaring problem for researchers of Christian Science is Campbell’s lack of distinction between groups.
View AnnotationPaths of Pioneer Christian Scientists (2010)
Four women— Emma and Abigail Dyer (daughter of Emma) Thompson, Janette Weller, and Annie M. Knott—were selected as representative of the pioneering work of early Christian Scientists due not to their gender, but to the available historical evidence, the range of their contributions to the history of Christian Science, and the relative familiarity of that person among today’s Christian Scientists.
View Annotation“When Parents Call God Instead of the Doctor” (2009)
The question of child-care in the context of serious health conditions always highlights the tension between medical and prayer-based treatments, and this tension usually turns on the First Amendment protection of religious rights. This article, written from the point of view that medicine is always superior to prayer, refers to prayer treatment as religion-based medical neglect.
View AnnotationPrescribing Faith: Medicine, Media and Religion in American Culture (2007)
Badaracco, a professor of communication, is interested in how 19th-century American religion advertised hopefulness, compared with how medicine preyed more on fear. In the chapter devoted to Christian Science, Badaracco emphasizes Mary Baker Eddy’s use of publishing and branding to spread her ideas. She underlines Eddy’s religious conservativism rooted in the Bible and the importance of Eddy’s female religious leadership.
View Annotation“Textual Healing: Mainstream Protestants and the Therapeutic Text, 1900–1925” (2006)
The focus of Klassen’s study is the healing practice of mainstream Christians in the US and Canada during the early 20th century. She argues that it was unabashedly medicalized and modern and was supported by the therapeutic role of written texts. Christian Science enters the discussion as a perceived opponent with its innovative reading of biblical texts.
View Annotation“From Quackery to ‘Complementary’ Medicine: The American Medical Profession Confronts Alternative Therapies” (2005)
This article examines the medical profession’s reaction to complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) especially during the last half of the 20th century. It includes no direct mention of Christian Science, but the subject is relevant to the understanding of Christian Science when it is categorized with other CAM treatments. CAM sometimes includes the religious healing practice of Christian Science.
View Annotation